Ophthalmic lens remand: nil for nine exporters, USD 0.30 for others
The findings answer two orders of the Customs, Excise and Service Tax Appellate Tribunal (CESTAT), both dated April 27, 2026. Final Order No. 50782/2026, on the appeal of the domestic industry, GKB Ophthalmics Limited, set aside the nil duty recommended on five participating exporters and sent back the non-injurious price (NIP) for fresh determination.
DGTR recommends nil anti-dumping duty on semi-finished ophthalmic lenses from China for nine named producers, including the four of the Essilor Group, and USD 0.30 a piece for all others. The Directorate General of Trade Remedies (DGTR), Department of Commerce, sets this out in its Final Findings in the remand proceedings, F. No. 6/6/2021-DGTR, Case ID AD/AA/001/2026 & AD/AA/002/2026 (Original Case No. AD (OI)-06/2021), dated November 2026 with no day printed, to be published in Part-I Section-I of the Gazette of India-Extraordinary, and signed by Amitabh Kumar, Designated Authority. It recommends that Notification No. 32/2022-Customs (ADD) dated December 27, 2022 be amended to levy the new amounts for the remaining period of validity of that notification. The 2022 findings had recommended nil duty for five participating exporters and USD 0.15 a piece on all other producers and exporters, including the Essilor Group.
The findings answer two orders of the Customs, Excise and Service Tax Appellate Tribunal (CESTAT), both dated April 27, 2026. Final Order No. 50782/2026, on the appeal of the domestic industry, GKB Ophthalmics Limited, set aside the nil duty recommended on five participating exporters and sent back the non-injurious price (NIP) for fresh determination. Final Order Nos. 50783-50793/2026, on the appeals of the Essilor Group, set aside the duty recommended on that group as non-cooperative and directed DGTR to consider its case afresh without treating it as non-cooperative. DGTR opened remand proceedings on July 14, 2026 (Case ID AD/AA/001/2026) and August 14, 2026 (Case ID AD/AA/002/2026) and took them up together. It held an oral hearing in hybrid mode on September 22, 2026 and issued a disclosure statement on October 27, 2026.
DGTR says the scope of the remand is confined to the fresh determination of the NIP and its consequential effect on normal value, dumping margin, injury margin and duties, including the margins of the Essilor Group as a cooperative producer/exporter. Its findings of September 29, 2022 on all other issues, including the product, the standing of the domestic industry, injury and causal link, remain unaltered. It re-determined the NIP under Annexure III to the Rules, considering the consumption of interchangeable raw materials on a group basis and expenses erroneously reported as non-PUC, and did not accept the claims to use actual capacity utilization in the period of investigation or to treat salaries and wages and other manufacturing overheads as variable costs. It constructed normal value for China on the re-determined cost of production, and did not accept a request to keep the proceedings in abeyance pending W.P.(C) 14723/2025 before the Delhi High Court.
The dumping margin of the Conant Group (Conant Optics (Jiangsu) Co., Ltd. and Shanghai Conant Optics Co., Ltd.) is positive, in the range of 5-15%. Those of the other participating exporters, including the Essilor Group, are negative or below the de minimis level. The injury margins of all the participating exporters are negative. For all other producers and exporters, the dumping margin is in the range of 60-70% and the injury margin 50-60%. Applying the lesser duty rule, DGTR finds that no duty is warranted on the participating producer-exporters.
The Essilor Group's four producers in China are Jiangsu Youli Optics Spectacles Co., Ltd., See World Optical Co., Ltd., Jiangsu Future Vision Co., Ltd. and Chemilens (Jiaxing) Co., Ltd. The individual duty rates apply only on a commercial invoice carrying the producer's declaration set out in the findings; without it, the duty for all other producers applies. The product remains semi-finished ophthalmic lenses made of plastic, excluding lenses with a refractive index higher than 1.60, polarized, polycarbonate, transition and high and special purpose lenses. Any appeal against the Central Government's order on these findings lies before CESTAT.
- Issued by
- Directorate General of Trade Remedies, Department of Commerce, Ministry of Commerce & Industry
- Document
- Final Findings in the remand proceedings, F. No. 6/6/2021-DGTR
- Case
- Case ID AD/AA/001/2026 & AD/AA/002/2026 (Original Case No. AD (OI)-06/2021)
- Dated
- November 2026 (no day printed)
- Product
- Semi-finished ophthalmic lenses made of plastic, from China; heading 9001 5000, indicative only
- Tribunal orders
- CESTAT Final Order No. 50782/2026 and Final Order Nos. 50783-50793/2026, both dated April 27, 2026
- Hearing and disclosure
- Oral hearing September 22, 2026 (hybrid); disclosure statement October 27, 2026; comments by November 3, 2026
- Dumping margins
- Conant Group 5-15%; Weixing de minimis; Carl Zeiss Vision (China), Daejeon Daemyung and the Essilor Group negative; all others 60-70%
- Injury margins
- Negative for every participating exporter; all others 50-60%
- Recommended duty
- Nil for nine named producers; USD 0.30 a piece for any other producer in China and for goods exported from China that originate elsewhere
- Previous duty
- USD 0.15 a piece on all others, under Notification No. 32/2022-Customs (ADD) dated December 27, 2022
- Period
- The remaining period of validity of Notification No. 32/2022-Customs (ADD)
- Not reopened
- Product scope, domestic industry standing, injury and causal link, and the cooperation status and export prices of the participating exporters other than the Essilor Group
- Signed by
- Amitabh Kumar, Designated Authority
Duty recommended in the remand findings
| S. No. | Producer | Country of origin | Country of export | Duty amount (USD per piece) |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | Conant Optics (Jiangsu) Co., Ltd. | China PR | Any country including China PR | Nil |
| 2 | Shanghai Conant Optics Co., Ltd. | China PR | Any country including China PR | Nil |
| 3 | Zhejiang Weixing Optical Co., Ltd. | China PR | Any country including China PR | Nil |
| 4 | Carl Zeiss Vision (China) Limited | China PR | Any country including China PR | Nil |
| 5 | Daejeon Daemyung Optical (Hangzhou) Co., Ltd. | China PR | Any country including China PR | Nil |
| 6 | Jiangsu Youli Optics Spectacles Co., Ltd. | China PR | Any country including China PR | Nil |
| 7 | See World Optical Co., Ltd. | China PR | Any country including China PR | Nil |
| 8 | Jiangsu Future Vision Co., Ltd. | China PR | Any country including China PR | Nil |
| 9 | Chemilens (Jiaxing) Co., Ltd. | China PR | Any country including China PR | Nil |
| 10 | Any producer other than those mentioned at S. Nos. 1 to 9 | China PR | Any country including China PR | 0.30 |
| 11 | Any | Any country other than China PR | China PR | 0.30 |
The final findings (remand proceedings) (PDF, 437 KB)
Source: DGTR's own copy.
Checked against the official copy on November 21, 2026.